The Most Trusted Online Casinos for USA Players Ranked

We give our honest take on the most trusted online casinos for USA players to play at, with reputation, safety and security in mind.

The online casino landscape in America is shaping up nicely. Many new U.S. states and casino brands have joined the party in recent years, ever since New Jersey kickstarted things back in 2013.

Now, there are four U.S. states where online casino gambling is fully legal. The following states are home to numerous fully-regulated online casino sites and apps:

• New Jersey
• Pennsylvania
• Michigan
• West Virginia

The Importance of ‘Trust’

The rapidly-growing online casino scene means that there are inevitably lots of amazing casino bonuses to be claimed. Even better, you can claim these bonuses while on the go, or in the comfort of your own home, with the click of a button!

So, you’ve decided that you want to open a new online casino account after seeing an enticing new customer bonus. What’s your next thought?

Well, more often than not, you will then be thinking “can I trust this online casino?”. No matter whether your idea of ‘trust’ relates to credibility of the brand, payment security, online safety, or anything else, ‘trust’ will always be top of the list when opening a new online casino account.

And that’s where we come in. At newamericancasinos.com, we have taken into consideration the most trusted online casinos for USA players. This is hugely important to most online casino fans and is invaluable information to have.

All online casinos promoted at newamericancasinos.com are here for a reason – because they can be trusted. However, here are our top 5 most trusted online casinos in the USA based on factors such as quality of product, reputation and payment security.

Top 5 Most Trusted Online Casinos for USA Players

Let’s get stuck in.

#1 – BetMGM Casino

BetMGM Casino is one of the most legit online casinos for USA players on the market.

The brand is extremely powerful. In fact, the majority of people in the United States and beyond will recognize the brand’s logo and its land-based properties. MGM Grand Garden Arena in Vegas, anyone?

Just like its eye-catching black and gold branding, the power and credibility of the MGM name certainly translates from offline to online with ease. We can assure you that there is absolutely nothing to worry about trust-wise when creating an online casino account at BetMGM and depositing money.

The fact that BetMGM Casino is available in all legal online casino gaming states also proves that there are no doubts around the brand from the likes of the NJ Casino Control Commission and the Michigan Gaming Control Board.

Not only that, but BetMGM’s online app is one of the best around. It is slick and easy to navigate around.

What is the BetMGM Casino Welcome Bonus?

BetMGM Online Casino is available in all four U.S. states. Interestingly, the BetMGM Casino welcome bonus differs depending on which state you are in. Here are the welcome bonuses on offer in each of the states that BetMGM Casino operates in:

Remember, use BetMGM Casino Bonus Code AMERICANBET during registration to guarantee your bonus!

1

Bonus up to:
$1,025
$25 Free Play and $1,000 Deposit Match Bonus
* New customers only. 100% match on first deposit.

3 games

4.8 rating

4.8

Play Now Read More

2

Bonus up to:
$2550
Welcome Package
* New customers only. 100% match bonus to $2500 + 50 Free Spins + $50 Free Play

1 game

5.0 rating

5.0

Play Now Read More

#2 – Borgata Casino

Borgata is an MGM-owned brand. Both Borgata and BetMGM operate online via ROAR Digital. As a result, everything mentioned above about BetMGM also applies to Borgata Online Casino. Just like BetMGM, the Borgata app is easy to use and slick. When depositing and withdrawing from your Borgata account online, you will have the same payment options as you would at BetMGM.

You may also be familiar with Borgata’s land-based property in New Jersey. Borgata Hotel Casino & Spa is a popular holiday destination for many, regardless of whether you are a casino goer or not. The impressive reputation held by Borgata’s New Jersey location translates online, with many using Borgata Online Casino as their go-to for playing online roulette, blackjack, slots, and more.

Borgata Casino is available to play online in New Jersey and Pennsylvania. There should be absolutely no doubts about using this online casino from a trust standpoint.

What is the Borgata Casino Welcome Offer?

If you are in New Jersey or Pennsylvania, you can claim a $1,000 Deposit Match Bonus from Borgata Online Casino. You will also receive $20 Free on sign up. No promo code required!

You may have tried BetMGM Casino already and. If you have, then why not claim ANOTHER bonus by signing up to Borgata too? The two platforms are almost exactly the same.

1

Bonus up to:
$1,020
$20 Free Play and $1,000 Deposit Match Bonus
* New customers only. 100% match on first deposit.

1 game

4.8 rating

4.8

Play Now Read More

#3 – WynnBET Casino

Ok, who can’t trust a brand that has Big Shaq leading the line on the marketing front? He is one of the poster-boys of American sport, and he trusts WynnBET. So why shouldn’t you?

In all seriousness, WynnBET has built up an impressive reputation since its online casino and sportsbook launch back in 2020. WynnBET is owned by Wynn Interactive, the official online product of Wynn Resorts. The Wynn is one of the hottest hotel and casino resorts in Las Vegas, which many hope they will one day be able to step foot inside. Wynn Resorts also own the Encore Las Vegas (next door to the Wynn) and Wynn Macau.

Time to try NJ online casinos? The WynnBet NJ Promo Code is a nice one!

The global attraction for the Wynn in Las Vegas has certainly helped WynnBET’s pursuit to become one of the best online casino brands in the United States. There are so many games to choose from, with secure online payment systems in order to keep your money safe. WynnBET Casino is currently available in New Jersey and Michigan, with its online sportsbook available to try in six U.S. states.

What is the WynnBET Casino Welcome Bonus?

Anyone who signs up to WynnBET Online Casino is New Jersey or Michigan will be eligible to receive a $1,000 Deposit Match Bonus. Use WynnBET Casino promo code WELCOME during registration to claim.

In other words, make a first deposit and WynnBET will match the value as a Free Bet, up to $1,000! Not bad for one of the most trusted online casinos in USA.

#4 – Caesars Casino

This online casino/sportsbook brand has had a LOT of investment pumped into it in recent years. Previously William Hill, the Caesars brand is quickly becoming one of the big dogs in the online casino space.

With huge investment comes secure payments systems, reputable and safe online games, and a safety net of the word ‘Caesars‘. Most people know the Caesars brand by now. That should be enough to settle any worries or anxieties surrounding this online casino’s credibility!

What is the Caesars Casino Welcome Offer?

Caesars Online Casino is present in three states – New Jersey, Michigan and West Virginia. Regardless of which of these three states you are within, you will be eligible to receive a $2,000 Deposit Match Bonus. One of the highest-value bonuses available from one of the most trusted online casinos for USA players!

The Caesars Casino bonus code that you should enter when registering your new account varies by state. New Jersey has a different Caesars promo code compared to Michigan and WV. Here’s what you need to know:

1

Bonus up to:
$1,010
100% Deposit Match Bonus up to $1,000
* New customers only. 100% match on first deposit.

4.3 rating

4.3

Play Now Read More

#5 BetRivers Casino

Rounding off our list of most trusted online casinos for USA players is BetRivers. Owned by Rush Street Interactive, BetRivers has been around since online casino and sports betting became legal in the United States. That in itself should allow you to rest easy. Your money is safe at BetRivers and you can trust this hugely successful brand with your confidential information.

Similar to BetMGM, the online footprint of the BetRivers brand in itself should help you to realise just how legitimate and trustworthy this online gaming brand is. Its online casino is available in Pennsylvania, Michigan and West Virginia. Then, its online sportsbook is present in more than 10 states.

What is the BetRivers Casino Welcome Bonus?

BetRivers Casino players will receive a hefty $200 in Casino Free Play when opening new accounts and depositing $50+. In other words, make a first deposit of just $50 at BetRivers and you’ll get a $200 bonus!

Here is all of the information you need, including the relevant BetRivers Casino promo codes for each state:

1

Bonus of:
$200
Get $200 Free When You Deposit $50
* New customers only. 400% match on first deposit.

2 games

4.3 rating

4.3

Play Now Read More